What to check
Pick up a fishing rod, cast near water, and fight the fish against its pull. The easiest first spot is the jetty by Jason's first home in Key Lento: a rod stands by the white boat, and you take it with L1 on PlayStation or LB on Xbox. Away from a rod stand, open the equipment wheel near water and select the rod under Equipment. To cast, hold L2 (LT on Xbox) and press R2 (RT) — a longer wind-up sends the lure farther. Rotate the right stick slowly to work the lure until a fish bites, then press R2 (RT) to set the hook. While the fish fights, push the left stick against the direction it swims and keep turning the right stick to reel it in; pause reeling while it struggles hard, then reel again when it calms down. Press L3 and R3 together to use Focus and spot fish in the water before casting. You first learn fishing in Recalibration, a Chapter 1 story mission on Cal's boat, and Cal later texts you a fishing challenge — beating him earns the Baited My Tackle trophy/achievement. Rockstar also names Mount Kalaga National Park ("prime hunting, fishing, and off-road trails") and Gambit Bay as fishing spots. One thing sources disagree on: whether you keep your catch. GameSpot reported before launch that Rockstar said you cannot keep fish, while Eurogamer's guide to the released game says "You can keep your fish or throw it back" — treat keeping fish as unconfirmed until it is settled. Fishing also counts toward challenges: landing a 20-pound fish, catching three fish on each lure type in one day, and catching 100 fish unlocks the Fisheye cheat once the story is done.
Editorial support reference, not an official Rockstar support response. If the issue continues, report the exact error, platform, game version, and checks already attempted to official support.