What to check
- A stolen car is not yours until you register it. Stealing a car, parking it and registering it are three different things, and mixing them up is how cars disappear. - First, scan the car with the WAINK app on your phone. It shows whether the car is locked, alarmed or tracked, and what it would cost to register it for yourself. That way you know the price before you steal it. - To register a stolen car, take it to a Pay n Spray and pay the registration fee, or use Moses at Watkins Auto Parts from Chapter 2 onward — Moses introduces registration during the story at roughly the 30 percent mark, in the Port Gellhorn part of the campaign. Not every car can be registered right away: tracker removal and higher-tier cars unlock through progression with fences, so a car you love may have to wait. - Until a car is registered, it shows as a gray icon on the radar and stays in the world for a while, but it is gone once you restart the game. If you find a car worth $50,000 before you can register it, park it in a garage — a stolen car parked in your garage stays safe even though it does not yet belong to you. - You start with very little room. Rockstar North's Rob Nelson told Famitsu you start with room for three personal vehicles, and when all three slots are full you have to sell one before a new car can join them. GameSpot's launch guide reports four owned vehicle slots at Moses' shop instead, so the exact starting number is still in dispute — plan around three and treat a fourth slot as a bonus. - To own more cars, buy garages around Leonida. There are 8 garages to buy, priced from $4,000 to $40,000, or $160,000 for all eight, which unlocks the Little Boxes trophy or achievement. Each garage also has a weapon locker and a secure spot to leave stolen goods for the local fence. - More garage space also comes from the story. Midway through, a character named Valentina hooks you up with a garage in Ocean Beach that immediately gives you two extra owned vehicle slots. The pre-order Shore Court garage near Ocean Beach and the Ultimate Edition Paradise Garage in Watson Bay are bonus garages on top of the eight for sale. - If your slots are full, sell a car before stealing another one. Our guide to selling cars through Moses and Pay n Spray covers the payout side: https://freeroam.fyi/guides/gta-vi-how-to-sell-cars-moses-pay-n-spray-randy
Editorial support reference, not an official Rockstar support response. If the issue continues, report the exact error, platform, game version, and checks already attempted to official support.